Across the USA, farmers markets are growing by leaps and bounds. But
how much is a leap? Can you quantify a bound? Public officials,
neighboring businesses, prospective vendors, and other inquiring minds
want to know. And farmers market organizations themselves want
to be able to quantify their accomplishments.
But all too often farmers market organizers are reluctant to take
on the task of measuring their success. Most have never done
an “economic impact study” before and the prospect can
be intimidating.
That’s why we created SEED, so that you don’t have to
repeat our learning curve. You can benefit from our mistakes.
Since we established the Crescent City Farmers market in 1995, we’ve
commissioned a series of studies. Each time we fine-tuned our
methodology, often with different partners. In 2002, the F.B.
Heron Foundation awarded us a grant to develop a simple measurement
tool that others could also enjoy. We contracted the services
of renowned Loyola University pollster Edward
F. Renwick, Ph.D.,
to conduct the studies and tabulate the results. A seasoned political
pollster, he brought scientific discipline to our table. His
full reports of market shoppers and vendors are
available in PDF formats. Based on his findings, we identified the
parts of the studies that worked, the parts that didn’t. We paired
down the methodology to be simpler, easier to use. Then, with
help from the awesome Outpost
Design, we developed this online
application for you to use at no cost.
Economic impact 101.
For those of you new to this number-crunching exercise, let us warn
you that other peoples’ studies always look far more scientific
than your own. It just comes with the territory. For instance,
while a corporate chain store’s study (for a new gargantuan store
they wish to bestow upon your community once the zoning ordinances
have been relaxed) may look bright and shiny, their use of projected
sales and multiplier effects is no more scientific than interviewing
and counting shoppers’ attendance at markets.
Briefly, SEED provides you with a user-friendly method to estimate
the gross receipts at your market, the number of shoppers in attendance,
the neighborhoods in which they reside, the dollars they spend at nearby
stores, and the frequency of their market attendance, and the sales
per square foot (speaking the language of retailers and developers).
Interviewing a representative sampling of shoppers will give you the
data to input into your SEED account, along with the final tally of
shoppers who attended the market on the day of the study. We recommend
multiple study days to gain greater accuracy.
Nearby retailers will be most interested to learn how many shoppers
and dollars the market brings to their stores—numbers that may
help you build support for the institution in your neighborhood. Rural
legislators will be interested to learn how an urban initiative—a
public market—benefits their constituents, i.e., your vendors.
Regardless of which party you are addressing, each will find some piece
of self-interest in the multiplier effects that emanate from a single
market. For a wonderfully simple explanation of multiplier effects,
let us direct you to the Augustana
University College study of its campus upon its surrounding community: “multipliers
capture the impact of an initial round of spending plus the impacts
generated by successive rounds of re-spending the initial dollars within
a region. The multiplier process traces the flows of spending and re-spending
that take place in the region until the initial dollars have completely
leaked to other regions.” The greater the interaction each
dollar has with the local economy, the larger the multiplier (or in
our language, the “stickier” the economy).
Step 1:
Learn about SEED
You are doing that now. Log onto marketumbrella.org to visit the SEED
homepage, where you will find a full menu of background, hints, and
instructions as to how you can use this tool to measure the stickiness
of the dollars in your market and upon your local economy. This device
will help you measure the economic impact of your public market for
both internal and external audiences. It is designed to take an otherwise
intimidating exercise (economic measurement) and make it simple. We
have been running public markets since 1995. From our markets’ early
days, we observed the direct economic activity within the market as
well as the multiplier effects upon the wider economy; however, we
couldn’t afford to hire expensive researchers to provide us with
reliable numbers. We did not possess the skills to conduct research
ourselves. And most importantly, we learned that many other markets
shared our frustration of experiencing economic impact but unable to
measure it. Please continue reading to learn how to use SEED.
You will be asked to create an organizational name for your account,
password, and provide important information about your market organization.
Please fill every field. All questions are pertinent to create a profile
for your full study.
You can return to your profile page to update information once
you have established your account.
We will send you an automated response confirming your account
name, password, etc. Please print this page and file it away. It is
all too easy to forget this information. You will continue to use the
same login and password regardless of whom on your staff or among your
volunteers inputs the study results.
With an account for your organization, it is a good time to establish
a profile for the market you wish to study. Some of this work requires
some low-tech tools and others can be completed on-line.
Log onto
your account and select “Markets” from the menu at the top of the
page.
This
takes you to your “Markets” page. Here, you can add or edit your
markets listed in your SEED account.
What
kinds of information do you need before setting up your market profile? Have
on hand your market’s name, location, day of operation, number of days
open per year (for instance, a year-round Saturday market would be open 52
days), and zip code.
Also, it is essential that you measure the size of your market stalls.
What does that mean? In order for SEED to calculate the sales per square foot
in your market, we need to know the average size of your market stalls. While
the rules for the sizes of vendor stalls may vary greatly from market to market,
chances are you have an “average size.” Some markets let vendors
stray way out into the aisles; whereas others, require a vendor to fit squarely
beneath the ceiling of the E-Z Up tent. Realizing these variances,
here is what we want you to do: measure the length and width of your vendor
stalls. If your spaces include the space for their vehicles, then include them
in the measurement. Once you’ve got the length and width, multiply the
two numbers and you have the square footage for your typical or average vendors’ stall.
If, on the other hand, your sizes vary, then measure the largest stalls’ length
and width; multiply the two numbers. This number gives you the square
footage for the largest stall. Measure the smallest stall’s length
and width; multiply the two numbers. This number gives you the square
footage for the smallest stall. Add these two square footage calculations
together; divide two; and you get what’s close enough to the
average stall size. Is it accurate enough? We think so. Even if your
numbers err on the side of caution, the efficiency per square foot
will be so staggering that your study can afford a few extra square
feet.
Once you calculate the average square footage per vendor stall, please
input this number into your market profile.
Please note: while your account’s details remain in the private
domain, in exchange for free use of this tool, we wish to post your
total economic impact on our site in order to help make the case to
public and private investors that public markets are sound social and
economic investments in their communities.
Also, please note: While the current tool is designed for US dollars
and antiquated measurements like feet, we’re working on a more
useful set of measurements for future updates of SEED. After all, the
concept is universal.
Step 3:
Download your SEED study forms
This is the easiest step: Simply download and print the forms
you will use to interview shoppers, and a cover sheet to keep your
information organized and your exercise orderly. You can find the
forms (in PDF format) under the Forms tab at the top of each page.
Select the date you wish to conduct a study at your market.
Assemble all of the personnel and tools that you will need for
the day: study forms, pencils, clipboards, a 9” x
12” envelope to transport the completed study forms back to
your office; a hand clicker, name
tags for the team, and a camera to photograph the market day.
Print out a SEED packet. It should include the following forms.
SEED
cover sheet: It serves as a checklist and cover sheet for
all of the paper you will accumulate.
SEED
pollster form: This form is designed to save you paper. Each sheet
contains 15 interview forms. Make more copies than you think you will need
on the day. Since you will be repeating the exercise (right?), you can
save the extras for the next time.
[OPTIONAL] SEED
forager form: Designed to assist you
in capturing qualitative data by interviewing market neighbors.
The information gathered using this form is not used in SEED.
[OPTIONAL] SEED
vendor form: Like the forager form, these optional interviews cannot
be incorporated into the quantitative SEED formulas; however, it may provide
you with answers to questions you’ve found difficult. We recommend that
the Study Directors distribute this form.
Also recommended
to keep your materials together: A 9”x12” envelope
for all of your forms. Either write details about the date and location of
the SEED study on the outside of the envelope or glue the cover sheet
to the outside. (Optional: if you are conducting vendor interviews, provide
an envelope or a box for vendors to drop their anomymous answers in.)
This is a good time to assemble your team. Who are they? market
volunteers? Board members? University students? Vendors’ kids?
There is no one good answer to this question of who’s best for
the task. It varies depending upon the issues in your market and the
ability of your organization to provide guidance to the team.
Should
you pay for the services? It doesn’t hurt to provide incentives (like
a market T-shirt or canvas bag). Moreover, if volunteers are too difficult
to find, then pay for the services. After all, you often get what you pay for.
How
many team members do you need? We recommend four skill groups: Study Director,
Clickers, Pollsters, and Foragers.
The Study Director: It is important to have one person who facilitates
everything. This is the individual who coordinates the team, keeps possession
of the Cover Sheet, and hands out (and receives) completed forms. The Study
Director can be the market Manager; however this may depend on the level
of responsibility that he/she has. If you are conducting vendor interviews
(optional), we recommend that it be this idividual who distributes the forms.
The Pollsters: They should interview between
10 and 25% of the shoppers in attendance on that day. It goes quickly
so don’t be intimidated by that number. Who knows? You might
even do more than that. Moreover, we discourage you to end interviewing
too early. It is very important to capture the shoppers who attend
at all hours of the market: The “early birds” and the “afternoon
owls” both possess useful information for your research. Depending
upon the size of your market, we recommend between two and four pollsters
at a time.
The Clickers: They are there to literally “click” the
number of shoppers entering the market with a hand-held number clicker.
This position is well suited to “detail people” who like
to quietly work on their own. We recommend shifts no longer than two
hours in length. So, if your market operates for four hours, then you
need two clickers.
The Foragers: Just as a mushroom forager searches for fungi
on the forest floor, the market should designate one or more individuals
to forage for anecdotal research from the surrounding neighborhood
during the hours of the market. Send a team member out into the neighborhood
to interview a residential neighbor who’s washing his/her car
or a shop owner who’s open during market hours. This will provide
your market with great, qualitative analysis or stories from which
to hang the numbers. The numbers impress but the stories stick in people’s
minds.
Train your team. Prior to a SEED study day, bring the team together
for a meeting. Walk them through the steps.
Provide
the team with a typed script in spoken vernacular. There’s no point in
writing something too formal or too long. They will simply adapt or edit down
individually to conform to their personal styles. Ideally, they describe
what they are doing at the market and why in the same manner.
Script for clickers: “Hi, I’m _______. I
am counting the number of shoppers in attendance today in order to
help the _______ market to better serve you.”
Script for pollsters: “Hi, I’m _______. I am
conducting a brief study for the _______ market.
May I ask you a few questions so that the market can better serve you?
It won’t take long.”
Script for foragers: “Hi, I’m _______. I am
interviewing neighbors in order to help the _______ market
to better serve the neighborhood. May I ask you a few questions? It
won’t take long.” [Again, an optional track of SEED.]
Script for study director: “Hi, I’m _______. I am
distributing a questionaire to vendors today, so that we can gather
information to help us make the market better. It should take five
minutes today to fill it out. Before leaving the market, you can put
it in this envelope (or box on market table). We don’t want to know who
handed in which form, so please do not put your name on it.” [Please
note: It’s a good idea to offer a free coffee or water when they hand
them in. Again, this is an optional SEED step.]
Conduct role-playing. A fun, easy way to get your team prepared and
excited for the job is to set up a meeting a few days in advance of
the selected date in order to conduct some role-playing exercises.
Prepare them for the occasional disappointment when shoppers refuse
to be interviewed; or for the scenario when more than one team member
asks to interview the same shopper.
Decide
in advance where you’d like for the “clicker” to stand (on
an elevated knoll, atop a ladder, or before a second floor window) so as to
attain the best view of shoppers entering the market. Together with your team,
observe a map of the property to discuss the flow of shoppers, vantage points,
etc. Please note: This exercise can often shed light upon the flow of the market,
official and unofficial entrances, and public safety.
Stick
to the methodology. SEED is designed to work with hard numbers. Explain to
your team that they should use the pollster form as it was designed – no
stories scribbled into the margins or numerical ranges provided as answers.
These only skew the outcomes and the accuracy. If, for instance, a shopper
answers to a question “between $20 and $30,” then we recommend
that the pollster assigns a value of $25 and/or asks the shopper to be more
specific: “If
you say between $20 and $30, do you mean $25?”
Tip: Encourage your team to dress alike in some form or fashion. Provide
them with nametags, a market hat (something that also doubles as their
in-kind payment for the volunteer service) or T-shirt. They should
look “official,” so as not to scare the shoppers.
Step 4:
Conduct a study at the market
Choose one or more market dates to conduct a study. Assemble a group
of market volunteers to help out. How
many volunteers? As we said before, that depends on the size
of your market, the number of entrances, and so forth. Instead
of volunteers, should you hire professional pollsters? Pollster
Ed Renwick says yes. Our experience, however, has been that shoppers
are eager to participate, if you tell them two things: 1) the interview
is only five questions long; 2) it will help the market. As a result,
we think you can get good results with volunteer pollsters.
Here’s the team we recommend you assemble before each polling
day:
One SEED Study Director to manage the team and keep materials together.
The Study Director may also conduct optional vendor interviews.
One or more Pollsters to interview shoppers. (two per two-hour shift)
One or more Clickers to count the number of shoppers in attendance. (one
per two-hour shift)
One or more Foragers to travel into the surrounding neighborhood to capture
anecdotal information from retailers, taxi drivers, residents, letter carriers,
and so forth, on how life is different in their neighborhood on market days.
(If you choose to utilize this optional track of interviews, we recommend
one per day. You don’t want to overwhelm your neighbors with packs
of market walkers and talkers.)
Outfit the team with recognizable identification (such as a market
T-shirt, badge, or logo sticker) so that shoppers and other respondents
quickly understand who is conducting the research and why. As
a result, pollsters will also feel more confident approaching strangers.
The interviews will go more smoothly.
Study Director:
This is your point person who will follow the study from start to finish.
This person invests considerable time planning, training, managing the
team and is responsible for seeing the completion and return to the office
for all forms. For small organizations, this could be the Market manager.
It could also be an oppotunity to groom a new board member who’s itching
to get their hands on a concrete task.
Clickers: How
do you count the number of shoppers in attendance? First, we recommend
you purchase a hand-clicker, available from office supply stores everywhere,
to enable Clickers to count the number of shoppers in attendance at
the market. Station the Clicker at the entrance to count shoppers as
they arrive. If there is no single entrance, station the Clicker across
the street from a good vantage point to observe foot traffic. If there
is no location that can observe all entrances, then your job is indeed
difficult. We realize that. Do the best you can. If clicking is simply
not going to give you the accuracy you’re looking for, consider
this alternative: Place greeters at the entrances to place gold stars
on each shopper. Explain to shoppers why, if necessary. From there,
you count each roll or sheet of gold stars. While this job is
relatively simple, it is also tiring. Whereas the Pollsters may
finish their interviews in less than an hour, someone needs
to count customers all market long. We recommend lining up enough
Clickers so that no one is stationed for more than two hours.
Who is
a “shopper?” We recommend counting anyone who walks or rolls into
the market on their own steam. Count adults, kids, but not infants.
Extra
tools that might be useful: a short ladder, camera, chair, an umbrella for
sun. Also, the SEED Study Director should check in on the
clicker from time to time: bring coffee, water; relieve them for bathroom
breaks, etc.
While
other methods of counting shoppers may exist, we have found the very act of
searching for the ideal location from which to observe the market and its entrances
is itself helpful to learn the logistics of entering the market, obstacles,
directional flow, and the rhythm of shoppers. It is for this reason that we
recommend that the clicker mark down at half-hour intervals the running count
on the checklist. You may be surprised as to which hours are the busiest.
Pollsters:
Station your Pollsters at the entrances to the market. (We have found
that interviewing shoppers upon their departure is challenging. With hands
full of produce, they’re less likely to stop for long to answer questions.
However, if shoppers are in a hurry to shop, ask them if they would be
willing to help you on their way out.) Or, go to a popular vendor’s
line. Start from the back and work up to the front of the line. After all,
you’re
providing the shopper with entertainment while they’re waiting for their
favorite products. Skip every other shopper in line; otherwise, respondents
may parrot what they’ve just heard.
Do not interview entire groups, married couples, etc. They too may simply
parrot what they’ve just heard. Instead, interview the one member of
a group and then move on. What happens if the shopper responds with “I’ve
already been interviewed?” Say “thank you” politely and
profusely. Tip: Place green stickers or a gold star upon the lapel on each
shopper interviewed as a means to communicate to other members of the team
not to bother the shopper again.
Make
sure Pollsters have a short script that describes who they are, what they’re
doing, and why. It need be no more complicated than, “Hi, I’m
Denise, a volunteer for the market. Would you be willing to answer a
short, five-question interview that will help the market?” If shoppers
want to know how it will help the market, Pollsters should be able
to give them a basic answer to that, as well. (“It will help us
quantify our benefits to shoppers, farmers, and the community.”) See
“Step 3” for three different scripts.
How
many shoppers should you interview? The short, unscientific answer is, “As
many as you can.” The more shoppers you interview, the more accurate
your results will be. If you count 1,000 adult shoppers attending your
market, attempt to complete as many as 100 interviews on that day; however,
250 would be even better.
Be careful of young Pollsters: They
may be too intimidated to approach older shoppers. Make sure that they do not
skew the research. They should not stand in place. Shoppers may learn how to
avoid the Pollsters. Circle the market; approach lines (as described above).
If the team seems to be having difficulty, we recommend managing by example.
Take the clipboard from a team member at the start of his/her shift and conduct
a few interviews to show just how easy it is to do. The same can be said for
the Clicker. It is an opportunity to point out the best place to count when/where
a shopper “enters” the market. Are there other ways of gleaning
information from shoppers other than to interview them? Yes. You can
set up a table at the entrance offering free beverages or cookies for shoppers
who fill out a form themselves.
Foragers: While the quantitative team members are busily examining
shoppers, consider sending an experienced volunteer with good communication
skills out into the neighborhood. If personal safety is a serious concern
in the market’s neighborhood or if your market enjoys an adversarial
relationship with neighbors, you may wish to decline this optional
track of SEED. Or, why not send foragers out in pairs and/or with senior
market leadership? This might be a good time to run interference with
neighbors who remain unconvinced that the public market serves their
interests. Using the foragers’ form to capture
stories in an organized format, make sure that your foragers get the
names, spellings, and contact information for the individuals they
interview. You will likely need to follow up for accuracy’s sake.
Since issues may vary from market to market, please give your foragers
some guidance as to what may illustrate the effects of the market upon
the neighboring residents and businesses. Does the market create parking
nightmares? Or, does it drive shoppers to area businesses? Do residents
value the market in their neighborhood? What is their opinion of the
institution? Do they know who runs it and why?
At the end of the market day, organize all of your materials
for the individual who will input the data into the SEED account. You
should bring back the following:
SEED
cover sheet, containing vital statistics, like number of shoppers and vendors
in attendance, list of supplies and volunteers, and date of the study.
Pages
and pages of pollster forms from the Pollsters. Number these pages once your
Pollsters return them to you filled out. It helps you keep track of what’s
what.
Supplies,
like the clicker and pens. We recommend keeping everything in an envelope or
shoebox. When you’re ready for your next SEED study day, you will have
some of the materials ready to go.
Step 5:
Create a SEED sub-account for the market you
studied
Log onto your SEED account.
If you have already created a sub-account for your market, then
select the “Studies” button from the menu at the top of
the page. This will
take you directly to the page where you may either create a “new
study” or
contribute to one you have already established.
OR
If you have not yet created a sub-account for your market, then select
the “Markets” button from the menu at the top of the of
the page. This will
take you directly to the page where you may either create a “new
market” or
edit an existing one’s profile by selecting the appropriate button.
Once you create market sub-accounts, you don’t need to create
new accounts for these markets every time you conduct a study. Just
log onto your SEED account and select that market (the Saturday market,
for example) from the menu and input your new data.
Identify a computer-savvy person to input the data. While not particularly
complex computer work, you don’t want to have to explain computing
basics to someone meant to assist your economic analysis.
Give them the time to do the careful inputting. We recommend at
least 90-minute intervals, any less than that can lead to confusion
as to when work started, stopped.
Don’t let study forms out of your sight. Once they’re
gone, they’re gone. Keep them at your office, never let staff
or volunteers input the results at their own homes.
If there is a question, or a problem (i.e., can’t read the
handwriting), do not let the person who’s inputting the data
make decisions as how to interpret the data on their own. Make sure
they come to you with questions. And, if you can’t answer them,
keep our contact information handy. We’re always here to help: seed@marketumbrella.org or
504-861-5898. Please note; We can help with issues pertaining to the
mechanics of using SEED, not how to read bad handwriting!
Step 6:
Enter your data into your SEED account
With all the completed pollster forms in front of you, make certain
that each is numbered and dated. Remember, this should have been done
at the market. Numbering the forms will help you keep track,
should they somehow get out of order. (And somehow, they WILL
get out of order!) Dating the forms will avoid confusion if you
plan to conduct a series of studies throughout the year. (You
don’t want to confuse forms from one session to the other.)
From the menu at the top of the page,
select “Studies” from the menu.
This takes you to a page that lists the studies you have already
commissioned in your SEED account. If this is a new study, then select
the button at the top left reading “New Study.” This will
set up a table into which you input study results.
Name
your study with something like “Sat Mkt, 05/07/2006.”
Input the date of study.
Input the number of estimated shoppers.
Input the number of vendors on the day.
Begin to input the results from your pollsters.
Remember, SEED studies capture a moment in time. The next
time you conduct a study for the same market, you will repeat this
step (as it will be another discrete study).
Once you have inputted the market profile, the study day’s
data, then you’re ready to create
a SEED report. Please note: This current step is a lot of work. It
may take a few days of inputting. In order to keep track of many pages
of study results, develop a plan to manage the stack of papers already
inputted and the stack of papers to be inputted. One suggestion is
to use a highlighter marker to indicate once a page has been inputted.
Once you’ve completed your inputting, select “Reports” from
the menu at the top of the page. Here you will be able to create a
report to download (as a PDF) and print.
Step 7:
Create a SEED report
SEED will walk you through the steps needed to tabulate your results.
For example, entering the number of days your market operates per
year will enable you to transform your single-day study results into
annual results, giving you projected annual gross receipts. (The
more studies you are able to conduct throughout the year, the more
your projection will match reality.) This multiplier, applied to
the other study responses, will also give you annual data for items
such as the amount market shoppers spend at nearby stores, and the
average annual amount shoppers spend at the market.
With projected gross annual receipt figures in-hand, you now have
the opportunity to estimate your overall economic impact by using an
appropriate multiplier effect formula. Which
one to use? Most studies use 2%, regardless of whether they fully
appreciate why. Is that such a bad idea? Yes and no. If you have the
resources, we recommend commissioning the Bureau
of Economic Assessment to determine
your appropriate multiplier effect. Administered
by the U.S. Department of Commerce, this is the service that many large
corporations use to determine their impact when planning production
or retail expansion. However, if you don’t have the resources
to commission their research, you can always play it safe with 2%.
Review your economic impact:
When SEED has finished with your data, it will give you a report that
shows:
The date of the report
The # of studies on which it was based (one, at this point)
The multiplier used
The sample size (how many total interviews were conducted) market Statistics
The total # of shoppers interviewed
The average # of shoppers per market
Estimated annual market attendance
Average $ spent at the market per shopper
Percentage of shoppers who spend at nearby businesses (per market)
Average $ spent at nearby businesses (per shopper)
Gender makeup of shoppers
Average size of market stalls (in square footage measurement) market Visitation Frequency Statistics
Rarely (%)
Several times/year (%)
Monthly (%)
Several times/month (%) market Economic Impact
Average gross receipts (per market)
Projected annual gross receipts
Project annual sales per square foot
Economic impact (using multiplier effect) market Economic Impact on Nearby Businesses
Average gross receipts at nearby businesses (per market)
Projected annual gross receipts at nearby businesses
Projected annual state & municipal tax revenue
Economic impact of increased receipts at nearby businesses (using multiplier
effect) Total combined economic impact (using multiplier effect)
Shopper Characteristics (by zip code)
Average $ spent per shopper, the estimated total # of shoppers, and the estimated
total amount spent annually, by zip code, as well as the
percent of total shoppers per market by zip code.
Step 8:
Share your market impact
So now you’ve got a couple of pages full of numbers. What
do you do with them? The answer depends on who you’re trying
to influence. If you’re trying to share the good news of
your accomplishments with friends, supporters, elected officials, prospective
funders or prospective vendors, neighboring businesses, or even other
organizations contemplating starting their own markets, you’ll
want to talk about your economic impact. “Our Saturday
market generates an average of $12,000/week in direct sales to vendors,” you’ll
say, “for total yearly receipts of $624,000 (the average weekly
amount times 52 Saturday markets/year).
“In addition, market shoppers spend an average of $15,000 each
week at businesses adjacent to the market, for an annual total of $780,000.
These additional retail sales generate $39,000 in taxes for local government
(if sales tax equals 5%).
“Moreover, the additional spending in our economy made possible
by the combined impact of the market and its effect on neighboring
businesses (its multiplier effect) is responsible for a total of $1,432,080
in annual income to our local community. (The sum of the market
and nearby retail sales, times the multiplier effect.) Not bad
for a little market that generates $12,000/week in direct sales to
local food growers!”
If you’re talking to a group of policymakers that includes rural
officials, you might point out that the $12,000 a week in total direct
sales to growers, divided by the number of growers at your market (perhaps
30), translates into an extra $400/week, or $1,600/month, in the pockets
of struggling rural residents and economies.
If you’re sharing study information with your vendors, you
might want to elaborate on the information contained in the study
data about Shopper Characteristics. You might, for example, point
out that shoppers from a few upscale zip codes make up a relatively
small percentage of your shoppers, but that they are responsible for
the largest volume of sales. Vendors might then speculate on
the interests of these consumers…for heirloom and specialty
vegetables, like arugula and baby bok choy, perhaps, or gourmet cheeses
and chocolate-dipped berries. On the other hand, the second-largest
percentage may come from two predominantly working class zip codes,
whose shoppers are interested in more conventional produce. Vendors
will also be interested to learn that these shoppers are responsible
for the second-largest dollar volume of sales (or whatever your study
data indicates).
In other words, SEED will supply you with a wealth of information,
but it will be up to you to help translate the information so that
its significance becomes apparent to your constituents. Pages
of numbers move few people other than accountants.
Choose pollsters who are outgoing, “people” people. There’s
no need for this exercise to be agonizing for anyone.
Choose an “average” day to conduct your study. Not
the busiest day of the year, and not the slowest, either. (Better
yet, conduct studies several times a year, such as once every
season; or at the start of the season, the middle of the season, and
the end of the season.)
Identify your pollsters with an organizational T-shirt, badge, or
sticker.
Ask prospective participants: “Would you be willing to complete
a short, five-question interview that will help the market?”
Attempt to interview shoppers on the way in. If they are in a hurry
to shop, ask if they would be willing to complete the interview on
their way out.
Ask people to narrow their spending estimate to a single figure, not
a range, even if it’s somewhat arbitrary. When you compile
your results, you’ll have to mark $10 or $20, not $10-$20. Ask
them to please give you their best estimate. If they cannot,
you’ll have to do it for them by entering the mid-point of their
range.
Attempt to interview between 10%-25% of shoppers in attendance that
day.
Your best to count every adult shopper in attendance.
Interview area merchants, residents, and others in the vicinity of
the market for anecdotal information on how the market impacts them.
Don’t:
Interview on the busiest day of the year; or on the slowest.
Choose reluctant pollsters.
Interview more than one shopper in a group. (They’ll tend
to parrot each others’ answers.)
Get in an argument with anyone, or attempt to force an unwilling participant.
(This may be more likely when attempting to get anecdotal information
from neighboring businesses or residents, than when interviewing market
shoppers.)
Stop after completing just one study. The more times you conduct a
study, the better your data will be!